
I've just read Manohla Dargis's review of the movie and she says that Von Stauffenberg was actually a much more complex person than comes across. Indeed, I think my main problem with the movie is that Cruise/VS and the other plotters (including Bill Nighy and Kenneth Branagh) do come off as overly one-dimensional. They are frustrated with how Hitler is using the German military, but there's no discussion of what they think a proper role would be. The Holocaust goes completely unmentioned and much of the movie is more of a plot-driven thriller than a character-driven exposition of opposition to Hitler and his policies.
237. The movie portrays the Bill Nighy general (and other coup-leaders) rather passively following Stauffenberg's directives. Stauffenberg was a colonel, though (I think) -- what was it about his personality or approach that made him the leader of the effort and caused his ranking superiors to trust his judgment/decisions?
238. I couldn't buy into Cruise in this role -- he's too much of a Hollywood star and his voice/inflection/tone sounded similar to all his other stuff. Why was he chosen for the role? Was it a purely financial decision or did the director/producers actually think he could bring some gravitas to the role?